This thread has been a wonderful trip down Memory Lane over the past year. Thanks to all the posters who shared their thoughts and memories. I have to say, however, that I am a little disappointed that the annual SVC memories stopped after the 1989 season. Because to me the SVC's finest hour on the grid iron came during the 1990 season.
To be clear, I'm not saying the 1990 season had the most talented players ever (actually, far from it). And I'm not sure if any of the teams were the greatest ever. But from top to bottom, the conference was never stronger. It's crazy to think but the mid 1980s to the early 1990s the SVC was considered the strongest football conference in the state and maybe the country too.
In the fall of 1989 the new Warren consolidated high school (which became Warren Harding) was accepted into the SVC for all sports, starting in the 1991-92 season. So the Raiders weren't technically eligible for the 1990 SVC crown. In fact they only played Fitch during the regular season. However I considered them an SVC team so I am including them in the stats below. On a side note, I think the 1990 season was one of the best seasons in Mahoning Valley history.
Mooney, Ursuline, Boardman, Fitch, and Harding combined for a record of 49-12 overall in 1990 which is unreal. During the regular season it was 42-8. However if you take away the games against each other the numbers become unbelievable. The five schools went a combined 35-1 against non-SVC schools during the regular season. And the one loss was by three points in OT. The schools were undefeated in regulation!
When they matched up with each other they produced some absolute classics: Boardman beat Mooney in an OT thriller by 1, Mooney beat Fitch in an OT thriller by 1, Fitch gave WGH one of it's toughest games of the season before losing by 6, and Boardman beat Ursuline on a last second FG. The one outlier happened in Week 10 when Fitch needed a miracle to make the playoffs: they spoiled Boardman's bid for it's first perfect 10-0 regular season by pounding BHS 38-0 in Spartan Stadium.
That result catapulted the Falcons into the playoffs. In fact all five teams made it which was unheard of at the time. This was back when there were still only five divisions and only 4 schools in each region made it. Boardman/WGH/Fitch all qualified in Region 1 along with St. Ignatius. Mooney's point total in Div. III would have qualified them in any region in any division. And Ursuline, despite going winless in conference play, still made it comfortably in. The schools ended up knocking each other out of the playoffs: Harding eliminated Boardman and Fitch and Mooney beat Ursuline in a Week 11 rematch. Harding of course ended up winning the Div. I title and Mooney was eliminated in the Div. III State Semi's by Richfield Revere (the only loss to a non-SVC team in regulation all year). While Fitch didn't make it out of the region they had the most impressive win that year IMO: they upset two-time defending state champions, St. Ignatius, in the Regional Semi-Final, ending the Wildcats' 39 game winning streak. It was St. Ignatius' only playoff loss from 1988-1995.
Lastly, while their record was gaudy, the teams these five schools beat during the 1990 season was a who's who of Ohio High School football. Their victims included: Lima Senior (1989 Div I State Semi-Finalist), Canton McKinley (x3; gave the Bulldogs 3 of their 4 losses that year), Lakewood St. Edward (x2), Steubenville (gave the Big Red their only regular season loss), Mentor, Massillon, Akron Buchtel, Toledo St. John (gave them their only regular season loss), Toledo St. Francis, Akron St. Vincent-St. Mary, Sandusky (gave Orlando Pace's team their only loss), Cin. Princeton (in the Div I title game), Mentor Lake Catholic (gave the Div. III AP Poll champs their only loss of the year), and St. Ignatius (see above).
I think it's safe to say we will never see a conference in the Mahoning Valley have a season like the SVC's 1990 one.